ONGOING RESEARCH / ENGLISH PROSPECTUS
From Coverage to Care
An investigative research prospectus on preventive health law in the United States, with a later Dominican Republic comparison
Prepared October 21, 2026. Status: initial research proposal; findings remain to be tested.
Recommended issue
Investigate whether health insurance and preventive-service laws ensure meaningful access to hypertension screening and follow-up care for low-income adults. Start with the United States and later compare the Dominican Republic.
Working title: From Coverage to Care: Legal Accountability for Hypertension Prevention in the United States and the Dominican Republic.
Central research question
When a low-income adult is entitled to a covered blood-pressure screening, what legal duties ensure that the person can obtain an appointment, receive appropriate follow-up, and challenge an improper denial or charge?
Distinguish screening from diagnostic evaluation, ongoing treatment, and medicines. A legal requirement to cover a preventive screening does not by itself establish free coverage for every subsequent service.
Why this deserves investigation
This subject connects health law to population health: early identification and sustained management of hypertension offer a concrete way to examine prevention, affordability, and continuity of care. Its legal focus is the allocation and enforcement of duties among governments, insurers, and providers, rather than a general description of health outcomes.
The United States offers a documented preventive-benefits framework. HealthCare.gov explains that most plans cover specified preventive services without patient cost sharing, generally through in-network providers. The investigation must establish the applicable service, population, plan type, exceptions, and legal rules before treating an individual charge as unlawful. [1]
The Dominican Republic provides a useful later comparison because its foundational health and social-security laws offer a different legal structure for examining similar access questions. PAHO’s historical system profile identifies Laws 42-01 and 87-01 as central to that structure; it is background, not proof of current statutory requirements. [2] PAHO’s July 2026 reporting describes ongoing primary-care reforms and gaps in coordination, information sharing, and follow-up between clinics and hospitals. [3]
WHO’s monitoring framework separately examines receipt of essential services and financial hardship. That distinction supports measuring access and affordability separately from insurance enrollment. [4]
Proposed scope
Begin with low-income adults ages 30–64 in one U.S. state, selected after a brief data-availability review. Examine applicable private-plan preventive benefits and Medicaid rules separately. Select one urban and one rural setting if records permit. Later choose Dominican settings with reasonably comparable service and socioeconomic characteristics.
Follow a defined care pathway: scheduling a screening; receiving the result; obtaining indicated diagnostic confirmation; accessing a follow-up visit and prescribed medicine; and seeking a remedy for an access or coverage problem. Analyze each stage under its own coverage and legal rules.
Questions to investigate
- What exact screening benefit applies, to whom, and under which statute, regulation, recommendation, and plan terms?
- Which follow-up services and medicines are covered, with what cost sharing or authorization requirements?
- Do provider availability, waiting periods, transportation, language access, or network restrictions impede use of a covered benefit?
- Which entity must address a failed referral or a lack of available providers? Is that obligation legal, contractual, or only an administrative policy?
- What complaints, appeals, external review, regulator enforcement, or judicial remedies are available, and how quickly do they work?
- Do available records show differences by income, rural residence, race or ethnicity, language, insurance category, or other relevant characteristics?
Working hypothesis and competing explanations
Hypothesis: coverage promises can leave gaps in actual prevention when patients cannot obtain appointments or affordable follow-up and when responsibility for continuity is unclear or weakly enforced.
Competing explanations include workforce shortages, geographic distance, patient preferences, clinical circumstances, and differences in the populations being compared. Do not infer illegality from a poor outcome, or infer a law’s effectiveness from enrollment figures alone.
Comparative framework
| Dimension | United States investigation | Later Dominican Republic investigation |
|---|---|---|
| Legal foundation | Applicable federal law, state law, Medicaid rules, and plan contracts | Current authoritative texts of Laws 42-01 and 87-01, amendments, regulations, and relevant benefit rules |
| Entitlement | Eligibility, covered screening, exclusions, and patient charges | Eligibility, covered services, exclusions, and patient charges |
| Actual access | Appointment availability, network capacity, distance, language, and follow-up | Same functional measures, adapted to local care organization |
| Responsibility | Duties of plans, agencies, and providers | Duties of relevant ministries, regulators, insurers, and providers |
| Enforcement | Complaint routes, appeals, enforcement actions, and remedies | Applicable administrative and judicial routes and evidence of their use |
| Results | Screening uptake, follow-up completion, financial burden, and blood-pressure control where comparable | Equivalent indicators with compatible definitions and years |
Compare functions and enforceable duties rather than assuming that institutions with different names perform identical roles. Compare national legal frameworks separately from findings drawn from particular local settings.
Evidence and reporting plan
- Build a legal authority table recording provision, effective date, covered population, responsible entity, enforcement mechanism, and source.
- Collect benefit documents, provider directories, relevant regulator reports, complaint data, and publicly available enforcement decisions.
- Seek de-identified information on appointment delays, screening use, follow-up completion, and patient costs. Record limitations in denominators, reporting periods, and missing data.
- Interview patients, primary-care clinicians, community health centers, insurers, regulators, and patient advocates. Use patient accounts to identify patterns requiring corroboration.
- Trace a small set of consented, documented care journeys. Do not collect unnecessary identifying medical information.
- Test whether observed barriers violate a binding requirement, reflect a policy gap, or arise from implementation constraints. Present these as distinct findings.
Proposed final document structure
Open with a documented care journey, explain the applicable legal promise, trace where access succeeds or fails, identify the responsible institutions and available remedies, and assess reforms against the evidence. Add the Dominican comparison after verifying its current law and comparable data.
Other viable topics
Maternal-health access and accountability; vaccination authority and equitable access; and migrant access to essential public-health services are alternative research directions. The hypertension topic is recommended because it provides a manageable care pathway and a clear way to distinguish benefit coverage, access, continuity, and enforcement.
Sources and next verification steps
[1] HealthCare.gov, Preventive health services: https://www.healthcare.gov/coverage/preventive-care-benefits/
[2] PAHO, Health Systems Profile: Dominican Republic (2007; historical background): https://www3.paho.org/hq/dmdocuments/2010/Health_System_Profile-Dominican_Republic_2007.pdf
[3] PAHO, Reorganizing health care: The Dominican Republic advances toward a more integrated health system (July 2026): https://www.paho.org/en/stories/reorganizing-health-care-dominican-republic-advances-toward-more-integrated-health-system
[4] WHO, Monitoring universal health coverage: https://www.who.int/data/monitoring-universal-health-coverage
[5] Dominican government legal-document index identifying Laws 42-01 and 87-01 (starting point for obtaining authoritative texts): https://cecanot.gob.do/transparencia/index.php/base-legal/leyes
Before drafting legal conclusions, verify the current U.S. statutory and regulatory provisions, applicable blood-pressure screening recommendations, relevant judicial decisions, the selected state’s rules, and authoritative Dominican legal texts and implementing measures. This prospectus establishes the inquiry; it does not establish a violation or a causal finding.